Birth Right Citizenship

[Catdaddy]

Explained.

https://x.com/BehizyTweets/status/18...874741/video/1

Sent from my motorola edge 2024 using Tapatalk

[Carolina Counsel]

I read an interesting article on it yesterday. As currently implemented, I believe it is unconstitutional (as an originalist).

[Sasha and Abby]

salty but correct

[tprice]

I read an interesting article on it yesterday. As currently implemented, I believe it is unconstitutional (as an originalist).

Do you think it will stick from legal standpoint ?

[PBiz]

I have issues with illegal immigration, but these guys coming from the South deal with a Government 100times more corrupt than the Biden Administration.

There is about a zero percent chance on becoming an American Citizen, legally, if you are from Mexico..

The folks with businesses and families here, are chasing the same dream our ancestors did.. Except they are building America, not killing Indians.

You could not give these people any aid or loopholes, and they would continue to flourish..

As a whole their family values are second to none and would vote conservatively if there was a proper pathway to citizenship.

But they lied to get here, outrunning feds and putting their life at risk..

However, I hope the bad guys get expelled and or kilt..

[Hogg]

Who is going to pick the cotton?

[JABIII]

To Phillip's point, it irks me that the ones out in the open getting it done at the jobsite are going to get rounded up, while the Chinese and Middle Eastern shitbags will be in hiding like the rats that they are...

[PBiz]

And the US Govt pays folks to come here and open Gas Station/Hotels..

And……. We let people stay in this country that hate it..

[PBiz]

Who is going to pick the cotton?

Not the sugar handed litigators that pay people to change their oil, cut their grass and clean their pools..

[Catdaddy]

And the US Govt pays folks to come here and open Gas Station/Hotels..

......and laundries.

They want any business that it's easy to siphon off money and hide it from the IRS.



Sent from my motorola edge 2024 using Tapatalk

[PBiz]

And the Spanish chaps I know pay taxes, and have never gotten returns.. So there’s that..

[PBiz]

https://www.instagram.com/share/BACq0iw26v

[Gander]

We have a legal pathway to citizenship. My father did it. My ex wife did it. It's not impossible but it does require a certain set of requirements. Our immigration system is setup to maintain a certain number each year which allows for assimilation. It's worked for 200+ years. You just have to follow it.

There are a lot of people in this country who came in legally from south America. Breaking our immigration laws is not acceptable.

[2thDoc]

i smell a little bit of sympathy for migrants. it smells funny. or am I just seeing the lighter side of the Biz?

i dont like mass deportation but I certainly agree with sending lawbreakers back, post haste.
I also want ALL migrants to pay taxes.

I dont know how we find the middle ground.

[PBiz]

We have a legal pathway to citizenship. My father did it. My ex wife did it. It's not impossible but it does require a certain set of requirements. Our immigration system is setup to maintain a certain number each year which allows for assimilation. It's worked for 200+ years. You just have to follow it.

There are a lot of people in this country who came in legally from south America. Breaking our immigration laws is not acceptable.

Did they come from Mexico?

Until Mexico’s system/government is fixed, I say the folks who have built most of this country in the last 40 years deserve amnesty..

[Glenn]

The Biz has been consistent on this. I remember reading similar post from him, what was it, 8 years ago?

The Biz works in construction and develops relationships with his co-workers so to him they aren't numbers on a data sheet, they're people. So he sees them not as a collective or a group to be lumped together but as individuals. So I understand A) his emotional attachment to the people who show up, work hard and help feed his family and B) the potential financial impact to not only to his business but to those of us who buy/sell/use those services. I'm sure he feels the same way about his honkies that show up, work hard and help feed his family. I know I do about mine.

This is the problem with blanket statements and policy. It removes the humanity from it all.

[CofC Waterfowler]

Not the sugar handed litigators that pay people to change their oil, cut their grass and clean their pools..

I cut my grass.

[Saltydog235]

I have issues with illegal immigration, but these guys coming from the South deal with a Government 100times more corrupt than the Biden Administration.

There is about a zero percent chance on becoming an American Citizen, legally, if you are from Mexico..

The folks with businesses and families here, are chasing the same dream our ancestors did.. Except they are building America, not killing Indians.

You could not give these people any aid or loopholes, and they would continue to flourish..

As a whole their family values are second to none and would vote conservatively if there was a proper pathway to citizenship.

But they lied to get here, outrunning feds and putting their life at risk..

However, I hope the bad guys get expelled and or kilt..

Yep. They show up to work every day, don't bitch and gripe, don't lay out, don't work long enough to game the employer or system to collect unemployment, most can pass a piss test and are about as loyal as it gets.

[mudflat]

Rather have 2 illegal Mexicans than one able bodied American getting any form of government aid for any extended amount of time.

[CofC Waterfowler]

Did they come from Mexico?

Until Mexico’s system/government is fixed, I say the folks who have built most of this country in the last 40 years deserve amnesty..

The major harm caused by illegals is to local schools. Their parents pay little to no property taxes but the kids get a free education. The local rural school districts do not have the resources to teach a class that is 70 percent non English speakers.