Man that has to hurt ...you both.. bummer.. Just another inch to the aft and he would be on the wall likely. Its a toss up on whether he makes it or not.. If the arrow breaks his odds go up, if it breaks at the insert odds up even higher. If he runs into a tree backwards then not so much... Antlers next year if he makes it will be down as its a bone injury that stopped the arrow. Bone injuries suck antler juice.