aaron rodgers

[2thDoc]

well, we must be a major site bc I agree he aint in the top 5


sorry, bart.

[Black Bart]

I'm gonna assume that y'all don't understand what I'm saying. And that's not a slight to anyone. Again, I'm talking purely about playing the position.

[Black Bart]

Question: Is Emmit the best RB of all time? He's got a lot of rings and accolades, but is he better than Jim Brown? Or Walter? Or Dickerson? Same situation here.

[ersepton]

Rodgers isn’t even the best Packers QB of all time.

[2thDoc]

I'm gonna assume that y'all don't understand what I'm saying. And that's not a slight to anyone. Again, I'm talking purely about playing the position.

you calling crackers stupid?

he is not in the top 5 QBs to play the position.
Hell, I might even put Favre ahead of him...

[Black Bart]

Never mind.

[FEETDOWN]

"GOAT" arguments in general are stupid, regardless of the sport. There's too many different metrics to go by. Team they played on, style of play, era they played in, etc.

Having said that, Brady and Jordan are inarguable.....

[Rubberhead*]

The only reason this thread got to two pages is because Deion didn't play QB...

[Black Bart]

Vincent Edward Jackson on line one...

[ecu1984]

Cole "three and out" Stout

[Fireman]

I'm gonna assume that y'all don't understand what I'm saying. And that's not a slight to anyone. Again, I'm talking purely about playing the position.

I understand where you are coming from. If you pull stats alone from many years they played together in the league he is better on paper than Brady. His ability to extend a play and throw a hailmary are unbelievable. Also his no look slant route throws are deadly accurate and just stupid talent. He is on par with Favre in my book at GB, but not greatest of all time. But in the end, even in the sports writer's books, it's all just an opinion.

[Black Bart]

I understand where you are coming from. If you pull stats alone from many years they played together in the league he is better on paper than Brady. His ability to extend a play and throw a hailmary are unbelievable. Also his no look slant route throws are deadly accurate and just stupid talent. He is on par with Favre in my book at GB, but not greatest of all time. But in the end, even in the sports writer's books, it's all just an opinion.

Fair take.

[Jozie & Me]

AR should have retired at Green Bay. He was a hero there no matter what you think of him. An athlete needs to realize when their spotlight is dimming and go out on a good note in a place they are revered. I figured AR would get damaged at NY. Hate to see it at this point in his career.

What drives someone to that level of excellence also clouds their judgement of when they are no more.

They all do it.

Montana in KC
Farve in MN
Etc

[Highstrung]

I had to google him.

[Highstrung]

then realized I've heard of him, he plays some golf

[ecu1984]

He's no Stephen Garcia

[TheVisorGuy]

Aaron rodgers is a shitty person. I don’t know him personally but some folks you don’t have to know them to be able to tell.

[Tater]

If I have one drive to win a game and I can pick my QB it’s going to be Brady without hesitation.

[Tater]

I’ll even go so far as to say if Rodgers doesn’t get hurt the Jets lose that game.

[murraywader]

He’s the greatest unvaxxed QB of all time.