You aren't going to have a policy that will satisfy all members I'm afraid. If you're in a club, there will be constant drama. Either set expectation...
I went with Big Marlin Charters in April. Very unimpressed. It was tourist fishing. Mate wasn't checking baits, etc. Capt wasn't moving spots to try...
We went last year and fished on Unbelievable with Capt. VJ Bell. We went 4/6 on whites and had a blue in the spread but didn’t capitalize. I believe...