We have two scags and just bought a Toro. I like and dislike things about both of them. The scag can cut through anything but are heavy. The Toro is the roughest riding I've ever been on but the seat is more comfortable and it blows taller grass out more evenly. Doesnt clump as bad. Overall I would choose the scag. Whatever you get dont get anything over a 60" deck or they will scalp bad.